MyTradeDiary bull logo MyTradeDiary Blog

MyTradeDiary Blog · Setups · November 8, 2026

Review Trades by Setup: See Which Setup Fits Your Plan

MyTradeDiary bull logo on a trading journal review by setup

When you review trades by setup, your journal stops being one long mixed list and starts showing you something useful: which setup you actually trade well, which one you rush, and which one only looks good in your memory.

Most traders judge themselves on the total for the week or the month. That total mixes everything together. A clean setup you followed well and a rushed setup you guessed at can cancel each other out, and the lesson gets lost. To review trades by setup, you split the record first, then read each group on its own.

What a setup name needs to do

A setup is the pattern you planned to trade before you entered. It is not how the trade ended, and it is not how you felt. Give each setup a short, plain name you will use the same way every time, such as the name you already write in your plan.

Keep the list short. If you have twelve names for almost the same trade, no group will have enough trades to teach you anything. If you have one name for everything, there is nothing to compare. For most journals, two to four clear setup names is enough to start. You can add a name later when a truly different plan appears.

The rule is simple: name the setup when you log the trade, not when you review it. Naming it later, after you know the result, makes it too easy to move a bad trade into a different group.

Review trades by setup, step by step

Step 1: Pick a clear time window. Use the last month, or your last 30 closed trades. Use the same window for every setup, so the groups are fair to compare.

Step 2: Group the trades by setup name. In MyTradeDiary, each trade carries its setup, plan, and lesson, so you can read the record by setup. If you journal elsewhere, sort your list by the setup column. Write down how many trades sit in each group.

Step 3: For each group, check plan-following first. Count how many trades in the group followed your plan, and how many did not. This comes before the money total, for the same reason How to Review Your Trades starts with the record, not the feeling: a group that broke its plan often teaches a different lesson than the total alone suggests.

Step 4: Then read the totals for each group. Write the number of trades, the total result, and your most repeated mistake in that group. Keep it to those three lines per setup. A short table you will actually read beats a long report you will skip.

What the split can show you

Sometimes one setup has most of your trades and most of your plan breaks, while another has fewer trades and a calmer record. Sometimes the setup you trade most is not the one you follow best. Those are not verdicts about the market. They are facts about your own habits, in your own record.

This is also where a small group needs care. Three trades in a group can show a habit worth watching, but they cannot prove a setup works or does not work. Treat a small group as a question for next month, not a final answer. Bigger groups, checked the same way over time, give a clearer picture — the same caution that applies when Backtesting Your Trades uses your own past trades to test one rule.

Turn the split into one lesson

End with one lesson, written in one plain sentence. For example: “On this setup, I broke my plan most often when I entered before my setup was complete.” Or: “I follow my plan most closely on the setup I trade least, so I need to slow down on my main setup.”

Pick the lesson from the group with the clearest pattern, not from the group with the biggest single trade. One big trade can hide a habit. A pattern across many small trades is the lesson your journal was built to find.

Then carry that lesson into your normal week. Make it the one fix in The 20-Minute Weekly Review: one fix, checked with a yes or no, until your next review by setup shows whether the pattern moved.

The one lesson to take from this

A mixed total cannot teach you which setup fits your plan. When you review trades by setup, each group tells its own story: how often you traded it, how often you followed your plan, and which mistake repeated there.

Your action today: take your last 30 closed trades. Group them by setup name. For each group, write the trade count, how many followed your plan, and the most repeated mistake. Then write one lesson in a single sentence, and check that lesson on your next trade.

Premium adds AI Insights, the prop firm challenge tracker, and mentor sharing. But the routine itself is free: log the trades, read the numbers, name the mistake, pick one fix.

Log it in a minute. Review it in twenty.

MyTradeDiary records each trade with its plan, setup, and lesson, then computes P&L, % return, and R-multiple for you — for stocks, futures, options, forex, and crypto. The journal is free forever; Premium ($15/month, with a 3-day trial) adds deeper analysis of your own record.

Start freeSee Premium & the Founding Deal