Backtesting Your Trades: How to Test One Rule Using Your Own Journal
Backtesting your trades does not need a coding project or a pile of spreadsheets. It starts with trades you already took, grouped in your journal, and one clear question you want to test.
In this post, backtesting your trades means looking back at your own record to check one rule. Did you follow it? What happened when you did, and what happened when you did not? It is a study of your own decisions — not a prediction, and not a promise about what will happen next.
Start with one question, not ten
A backtest fails when it tries to test everything at once. Pick one question you can answer with a yes or no. For example: “Did I write my planned stop before entry?” or “Did I trade only my main setup?” One question keeps the work small and the answer clear.
Write the question at the top of a note before you look at any results. That order matters. If you look first, it is easy to pick the question your best trades already answer well. Writing it first keeps the test honest, the same way How to Review Your Trades starts with the numbers before the feelings.
Backtesting your trades, step by step
Step 1: Pick a small set of past trades. Start with your last 20 to 30 closed trades, or all of one month if that is easier. Use trades from one setup if you can, so you are comparing like with like.
Step 2: Group them by one thing. Sort by setup, by day, or by whether you followed your plan. In MyTradeDiary you can read your journal by setup and lesson, and use the Backtest view to slice your own closed trades. If you journal elsewhere, a simple sort in your list does the same job.
Step 3: Count, do not guess. For each group, write down how many trades there were, how many followed the rule, and the total result for that group. Include every trade in the set — the losses too. Leaving out the trades you do not like is not a backtest. It is a story.
Step 4: Read the lesson, not just the total. A group can end near flat and still teach you a lot. Maybe the rule was followed on most trades and broken on only a few, and those few look very different. That pattern is the lesson, even when the money total is small.
Use the same trades and the same rule every time
Keep the test fair. Use the same date range for every group. Use the same rule wording for every trade. Do not change the question halfway through because the first answer was not the one you wanted.
Small sets need care too. Five trades can show you a habit, but they cannot prove a rule works. Treat a small backtest as a clue for your next review, not as a final answer. Bigger sets, checked the same way, give you a clearer picture over time.
What a backtest can and cannot tell you
A backtest of your own trades can tell you what happened in your own record: which setup you traded most, where your plan broke, and which mistake repeated. That is useful, honest information.
It cannot tell you what the market will do next, and it cannot prove that a rule will work in the future. Past trades are history. The value is in the habit you build from studying them — a clearer plan, written down, that you can check on the next trade.
Turn the result into one lesson
End the backtest with one sentence: the lesson. Write it in plain words, such as “On this setup, my plan broke most often when I entered without a written stop.” One sentence is enough. Long reports get filed and forgotten.
Then carry that lesson into your normal routine. Add it as the one fix in The 20-Minute Weekly Review, and check it daily the way One Fix at a Time describes: one fix, one yes-or-no check, until the next review.
The one lesson to take from this
You do not need new trades to learn something new. Backtesting your trades turns the record you already have into a test of one rule — what you did, what happened, and what you will check next time.
Your action today: pick one setup and your last 20 closed trades with that setup. Write one yes-or-no question at the top of a note. Group the trades by whether you followed that rule, count each group, and write the one lesson in a single sentence.
Premium adds AI Insights, the prop firm challenge tracker, and mentor sharing. But the routine itself is free: log the trades, read the numbers, name the mistake, pick one fix.
Log it in a minute. Review it in twenty.
MyTradeDiary records each trade with its plan, setup, and lesson, then computes P&L, % return, and R-multiple for you — for stocks, futures, options, forex, and crypto. The journal is free forever; Premium ($15/month, with a 3-day trial) adds deeper analysis of your own record.
Start freeSee Premium & the Founding Deal